Shipping policy

📦 Shipping Summary

At Subtle Shuffle, we offer multiple shipping options so you can choose the level of protection and tracking that best fits your order. Our Plain White Envelope (PWE) is the most affordable option but is untracked and uninsured, so we recommend choosing a tracked method for higher-value items. Our Standard Tracked Shipping uses secure bubble mailers to protect your cards in transit, and we offer free shipping on orders over $250, using the best available method with tracking and insurance included. Please review our full policy below for details on delivery times, costs, and returns.

✉️ Plain White Envelope (PWE)

  • Untracked

  • Uninsured

  • Minimal protection

PWE is best suited for low-value single cards. While cards are placed in a sleeve and top loader, this option does not include tracking or insurance.

If you are purchasing cards you wish to keep in immaculate condition, we strongly recommend choosing a tracked shipping option. Subtle Shuffle cannot guarantee condition, delivery confirmation, or replacement for items shipped via PWE.

📬 Standard Tracked Shipping (Bubble Mailer)

  • Tracked

  • Secure

  • Highly recommended

Orders are shipped in a bubble mailer with rigid cardboard support and additional protective wrapping to ensure safe delivery.

🚀 Free Shipping on Orders Over $250

Orders over $250 (before tax) qualify for free shipping. We will ship using the best available method based on order value, contents, and destination, which includes tracking and insurance.

❌ Final Sale Items

Due to the nature of collectibles and randomized products, the following items are final sale:

  • Single cards

  • Loose booster packs

  • Pre-owned merchandise

✅ Sealed Product Returns

Sealed products may be returned within 7 days of delivery, provided the factory seal remains intact and the item is returned in original condition.

Opened or tampered seals void return eligibility.